Swimming is a common form of exercise around the world. Swimming is practiced by all age groups and it has been recommended as a form of exercise for asthmatic patients for many years, it has been thought to less likely trigger asthma. However, evidence exists that implicates the aquatic environment itself is a cause of asthma through exposure of the airways to irritants such as chlorine. In a previous article, I discussed the risk of asthma by swimming in chlorinated pools indoors. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/06/04/AR2007060400464_pf.html
Asthma is diagnosed from symptoms of cough, wheezing, chest tightness and mucus production. Exercise induced asthma refers to narrowing of the airways resulting from exercise. It often occurs in dry/cold sporting environments such as ice skating rings or chlorine disinfected swimming pools. Exercise induced asthma can be of variable severity and it can affect an athletes health.
The presence of asthma in elite swimmers is due to many causes. For the competitive swimmer, high respiratory rates and volumes during training are implicated in the development of asthma through airway remodeling caused by chronic inflammation, epithelial damage or both. Also exposure to chloramines, a byproduct of chlorine can pose an increased risk to airway hyperresponsiveness. Inhaled chloramines are believed to induce disruption of the epithelial lining of the lung promoting allergen sensitization. Allergen exposure results in inflammatory mediators and sensitization of airway smooth muscle, leading to airway remodeling. Prolonged training in a chlorinated enviornment can lead to fibrogenesis of the airways resulting in asthma.
The ventilatory demands of endurance sports requires the athlete to breathe at a high flow for repeated prolonged periods of time over an extended career. Such demands result in cooling and dehydration of the airway mucosa, resulting in airway smooth muscle contraction. Mechanical stress can also disrupt to bronchial smooth muscle epithelium.
Because of variations in the training demands of aquatic disciplines, elite athletes may have different respiratory responses depending on their sport. Here we will look at synchronized swimming, open water swimming, diving and water polo players. It is important to understand the health risks of each aquatic sport.
It is hypothesized that there is a link between swimming and asthma. Also that there is a higher prevalence of asthma in aquatic sports than any other Olympic sport. Here we will look at the overall prevalence of asthma in aquatic sports, to assess differences in the prevalence in asthma between the aquatic sports and to compare them by geography.
Results- The prevalence of swimming and asthma in comparison to other aquatic disciplines was significantly higher. The highest rates were seen in North America and Europe, the lowest rates of asthma was in Africa and South America.
The high prevalence of asthma in swimming relative to other aquatic sports points to an etiologic factor other than environmental exposure, such as training intensity, type and/or duration. Studies have shown a high prevalence of asthma in endurance versus nonendurance sports, shows that endurance training is an etiologic factor in the development of asthma. It would be interesting to compare the rate of asthma in swimmers versus long distance runners.
The key conclusion is that swimming has a higher prevalence of asthma relative to other water sports. In addition, the data support the hypothesis that elite endurance athletes have a higher rate of asthma than nonendurance athletes. Geographic variations raise many questions that require further investigation.
Despite the increased risk of asthma in elite swimming, the physical, mental health and lifestyle benefits of participation in the sport are numerous when compared with the health of the general population.
